
It’s Always the Owner’s Fault! Or Is It?
“Owners are always to blame for their dog's behaviour!” How often have you heard that from other owners in the park, at the vet's, or read it in Facebook groups? Perhaps even at dog training school you were told that you were the main culprit because your “badly behaved” dog has trouble accepting other dogs. If you think about it, that sounds logical, doesn't it? You are the one who cares for your dog: you feed them, take them for walks, train them (or at least try to), play with them... From all this, you might conclude that their behaviour is entirely under your control. After all, we have long had the saying, “Like owner, like dog!” But is that really true? Are we the only factor that influences our dog's behaviour?
Behaviour is the product of an interaction between genes and the environment. The environment includes everything living and non-living that surrounds an individual. Because we are part of that environment, we influence our dog's behaviour through training and spending time together. But this is only one of the factors that shape their behaviour.
Even before a puppy comes into our home, certain factors have already left their mark on the development of their personality and therefore their behaviour. For example, prenatal stress experienced by the mother dog affects her puppies' physical development, learning and behaviour. Research shows that puppies exposed to prenatal stress may have less developed motor skills, greater difficulty learning and more difficulty adapting to new situations.
Experiences after birth are also extremely important, especially during the socialisation period, between the ages of approximately three and fourteen to sixteen weeks. During this time, puppies' senses develop, and they take in information about their surroundings through smell, sight, hearing, touch and taste. It is important for puppies to experience different stimuli during socialisation. Puppies deprived of these experiences, or those that spend the socialisation period in an unstimulating environment, are more likely to show fear in new situations later in life.
Early experiences also affect social behaviour later on. Puppies learn communication skills through interacting and playing with each other. Their mother plays an important role by teaching them the rules of behaviour and intervening when necessary. Puppies separated early from their mother and littermates — or those who never had the chance to spend their first months with them — may therefore find communication with other dogs more difficult later on. They may be more inclined to get into conflicts, or they may be reserved and timid. In addition, puppies separated from their mother early (before nine weeks of age) are more prone to anxiety when separated from their owner.
Experiences after the socialisation period, later in life and even in adulthood, can also change behaviour. For example, dogs that spend part of their lives in a shelter develop adaptive behaviours that help them survive in those conditions. But after they are adopted into a family, those behaviours can become a problem. A very common example is guarding food and other resources, such as toys or access to a place to rest and sleep.
As we have said, we influence our pet's behaviour through training, but the way we train is also important. Practical experience and scientific research show that training based on punishment and intimidation negatively affects dogs' behaviour. Dogs trained using these methods can become fearful, insecure and more prone to aggressive behaviour.
So what can we conclude? Dogs' behaviour is influenced by a range of factors, only some of which are under our direct control. We therefore cannot understand their behaviour solely as a product of our training and our relationship with them. With that in mind, we should ask ourselves whether it makes sense to blame and criticise owners whose dogs sometimes show behavioural difficulties. Some of these dogs did not have everything they needed early in life to grow into stable adults. Others were affected by experiences later in life that their owner may have had no control over — or that happened when the dog belonged to another family. Some owners may indeed have made mistakes in training, but they wanted the best for their pets.
Whatever the circumstances, accusing people and reinforcing that accusation with “Like owner, like dog!” certainly will not encourage the people on the receiving end. Quite the opposite: they will feel ashamed and frustrated, which often leads them to give up trying to solve the problem — and may even lead them to give up on their dog.
Let's not forget that we, too, are part of the environment and influence the behaviour of others. If we have the opportunity to influence other people, let's do it in a positive and constructive way.
Author: Igor Gaćeša, KA-DOG. English edition based on the Slovenian translation by Anita Gosnik.
